Episode 85: Good Trans, Bad Trans with Katy Montgomerie

After some small talk about the holidays, trans YouTuber, activist, and social media bon vivant Katy Montgomerie cheerfully and calmly explains how Gender Criticals aren’t feminist, believe in sexed souls, advocate for the elimination of trans people, and want to ruin Katy’s life. Unlike the sucking-up-to-the-oppressor trans friends of JK Rowling — whom Katy claims is openly hostile to trans people — Katy is NOT “one of the good ones.” Katy is, however, a good sport, and clearly elucidates a set of moral and policy positions. Good or bad? Listen and decide for yourself!


Katy Montgomerie on Twitter: https://twitter.com/KatyMontgomerie

website: https://katymontgomerie.com/

Adult Human Weirdo T-shirts: https://nina-paley-shirts.creator-spring.com/listing/adult-human-weirdo

T: The Story of Testosterone by Carole Hooven: https://us.macmillan.com/books/9781250236067/tthestoryoftestosteronethehormonethatdominatesanddividesus

The Dreger-Wright debate (December 12 2022): https://youtu.be/K2aKX8Mcz9Q

5 thoughts on “Episode 85: Good Trans, Bad Trans with Katy Montgomerie

  1. The point that Montgomerie avoids is the FACT that his life now is a total deceit; a confidence trick. The fact of this deceit is expressed via his choice to have facial feminisation surgery (something no female has to do); his choice to implant silicon shapes into his chest to simulate breasts (something no female has to do); his choice to ingest synthetic oestrogen to augment his feminisation (something no female has to do).

    Females have not consented and are unlikely to ever consent to Montgomerie violating their boundaries in single sex spaces and yet he says not allowing him to violate our boundaries will “ruin his life”. He expresses his male-centric view.

    Montgomerie can’t go back now because of his surgeries and medication, he is in the realm of sunk cost fallacy which leads him to make special pleading to continue to violate the boundaries of every female against their consent.

    For Montgomerie’s information, UK law defines sex as “the CONGRUENCE OF chromosomes, gonads and genitals”.

Comments are closed.